Middletown, NY Crime Statistics For 2026

The latest crime statistics for Middletown from FBI data. Includes murder, violent, and property crime rates for Middletown

Crime in Middletown, New York

Crime in Middletown research summary. HomeSnacks has been using Saturday Night Science to report crime data in Middletown over the past 9 years using the FBI Crime Explorer. Based on the most recently available data from the FBI's 2024 Uniform Crime Report, we found the following about crime in Middletown:

456 Total crimes
1,514.4 Crimes / 100k people
-28.54% Vs national average Below The National Average
#269 Safest in New York (of 376)
#6,071 Safest in the U.S. (of 9,896)

Additional research about crime in New York

Looking for somewhere safer? Try our place-match quiz →

Middletown Vs New York And National Crime Rates

According to the most recent data from the FBI, the total crime rate in Middletown is 1,514.4 per 100,000 people. That's -28.54% lower than the national rate of 2,119.2 per 100,000 people and -27.87% lower than the New York total crime rate of 2,099.7 per 100,000 people.

Statistic Count
Raw
Middletown
/ 100k People
New York
/ 100k People
National
/ 100k People
Total Crimes Per 100K 456 1,514.4 2,099.7 2,119.2
Murder 2 6.6 2.7 5.0
Robbery 16 53.1 96.1 61.0
Aggravated Assault 70 232.5 259.6 256.0
Violent Crime 93 308.9 380.2 359.0
Burglary 23 76.4 136.6 229.0
Larceny 322 1,069.4 1,432.8 1,272.0
Car Theft 18 59.8 150.2 259.0
Property Crime 363 1,205.6 1,719.5 1,760.0

Middletown Crime Compared To New York Averages

Murder
Middletown
New York avg
Rape
Middletown
New York avg
Robbery
Middletown
New York avg
Aggravated Assault
Middletown
New York avg
Burglary
Middletown
New York avg
Larceny
Middletown
New York avg
Car Theft
Middletown
New York avg
Arson
Middletown
New York avg

Each category indexed to the worst per-capita rate in New York. Source: FBI UCR 2024.

Worried about safety? Compare home security systems in Middletown Get matched →

Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (2024)

Violent Crime Rates In Middletown

93Violent Crimes
308.9Violent Crimes / 100k People
-13.96%Below The National Average
Middletown
US
  • There were 93 violent crimes in Middletown in the last reporting year.
  • The violent crime rate in Middletown is 308.9 per 100,000 people.
  • You have a 1 in 323.8 chance of being the victim of a violent crime in Middletown each year. That compares to a 1 in 263.0 chance statewide.
  • That's -13.96% lower than the national rate of 359.0 per 100,000 people.
  • And -18.75% lower than the New York violent crime rate of 380.2 per 100,000 people.

Property Crime Rates In Middletown

363Property Crimes
1,205.6Property Crimes / 100k People
-31.50%Below The National Average
Middletown
US
  • There were 363 property crimes in Middletown in the last reporting year.
  • The property crime rate in Middletown is 1,205.6 per 100,000 people.
  • You have a 1 in 82.9 chance of being the victim of a property crime in Middletown each year. That compares to a 1 in 0.0 chance nationally.
  • That's -31.50% lower than the national rate of 1,760.0 per 100,000 people.
  • And -29.89% lower than the New York property crime rate of 1,719.5 per 100,000 people.

Crime In Cities Around Middletown

City Population Count
Raw
Total Crime
/ 100k People
Property Crime
/ 100k People
Violent Crime
/ 100k People
O'Fallon, MO 94,911 511 538.4 479.4 59.0
St. Peters, MO 59,993 759 1,265.1 1,058.5 206.7
Wentzville, MO 48,377 413 853.7 744.2 109.6
Lake St. Louis, MO 19,334 128 662.0 605.2 56.9
Washington, MO 15,707 235 1,496.1 1,241.5 254.7
Troy, MO 15,240 171 1,122.0 977.7 144.4
Fulton, MO 12,431 161 1,295.1 1,086.0 209.2
Mexico, MO 11,531 296 2,567.0 2,384.9 182.1
Bowling Green, MO 4,460 32 717.5 672.6 44.8

Middletown SnackAbility

6Overall SnackAbility
Jobs 7/10
Housing 8.5/10
Affordability 5/10
Diversity 10/10
Safety 6/10
Amenities 9.5/10
Education 6/10
Commute 5/10