The 10 Cheapest Places To Live In Indiana In 2026

The most affordable places to live in Indiana for 2026 are Muncie, Marion, and New Castle according to Saturday Night Science.

Indiana is full of growing cities with good jobs. Good jobs increase median incomes. Higher incomes increase real estate budgets. Higher real estate budgets increase home prices. This logic means finding the most affordable places to live in Indiana is becoming increasingly important. We used Saturday Night Science to consult the latest Indiana Census data on the cost of living, home prices, incomes, and rents to find the affordable places in Indiana. Luckily, affordable places in Indiana include millennial cities like Indianapolis, fantastic college cities like West Lafayette, and cities like Hillsboro.
1

No. 1 most affordable place in Indiana

Muncie, IN

64,751 peopleSnackAbility 5/10up 9
5/10
Muncie, IN
Source: Public domain
$44,471 median income · $904 median rent · #9 home prices in Indiana
Map of Muncie within Indiana Located in Delaware County, Indiana
Median home value -40% vs IN
$151,291
IN $254k
Median income -38% vs IN
$44,471
IN $72k

Muncie is an incorporated city and the seat of Delaware County, Indiana. It is located in East Central Indiana, about 50 miles northeast of Indianapolis. The United States Census for 2010 reported the city’s population was 70,085. It is the principal city of the Muncie metropolitan statistical area, which has a population of 117,671.

2

No. 2 most affordable place in Indiana

Marion, IN

27,531 peopleSnackAbility 5/10
5/10
Marion, IN
Source: Wikipedia User Chris Light at English Wikipedia | CC BY-SA 3.0
$43,343 median income · $805 median rent · #4 home prices in Indiana
Map of Marion within Indiana Located in Grant County, Indiana
Median home value -46% vs IN
$136,313
IN $254k
Median income -40% vs IN
$43,343
IN $72k

Marion – no relation to my great-mother-in-law – ranks as the second cheapest city in Indiana. Located in Grant County, this city keeps living expenses down with a reasonable $805 median rent. The overall cost of living is 11.1% lower than the state average.

The money you’ll save on housing costs can be put towards a long weekend to watch the Colts in Indianapolis.

3

No. 3 most affordable place in Indiana

New Castle, IN

17,367 peopleSnackAbility 5/10up 24
5/10
New Castle, IN
Source: Public domain
$51,606 median income · $781 median rent · #18 home prices in Indiana
Map of New Castle within Indiana Located in Henry County, Indiana
Median home value -35% vs IN
$164,336
IN $254k
Median income -28% vs IN
$51,606
IN $72k

New Castle is a city in Henry County, Indiana, 44 miles east-northeast of Indianapolis, on the Big Blue River. The city is the county seat of Henry County. New Castle is home to New Castle Fieldhouse, the largest high school gymnasium in the world. The city is surrounded by agricultural land. In the past, it was a manufacturing center for the production of sheet iron and steel, automobiles, caskets, clothing, scales, bridges, pianos, furniture, handles, shovels, lathes, bricks, and flour.

4

No. 4 most affordable place in Indiana

Peru, IN

10,901 peopleSnackAbility 5/10up 9
5/10
Peru, IN
Source: Public domain
$46,159 median income · $826 median rent · #8 home prices in Indiana
Map of Peru within Indiana Located in Miami County, Indiana
Median home value -41% vs IN
$149,304
IN $254k
Median income -36% vs IN
$46,159
IN $72k

Situated about 60 miles southwest of Fort Wayne, Peru ranks as the fourth most affordable place to call home in Indiana. Peru was once the winter headquarters for several famous circuses, like the Ringling Brothers and Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show. It’s maintained that heritage into the 21st century with the annual Peru Circus City Festival and Parade, amateur circus performances, and the Circus Hall of Fame. That’s not the only outside-the-box entertainment option in Peru, though; there’s also the Grissom Air Museum for folks interested in learning more about military aircraft. For more standard activities, there’s always fishing or kayaking on Mississinewa Lake. Homes in Peru are the eighth cheapest in Indiana at $149,304, which is a big contributor to the city’s low cost of living. The median income in Peru is $46,159 and the media rent is $826.

5

No. 5 most affordable place in Indiana

Gary, IN

68,113 peopleSnackAbility 4/10up 40
4/10
Gary, IN
Source: Wikipedia User Chris Light (talk) | CC BY-SA 3.0
$38,731 median income · $1,012 median rent · #1 home prices in Indiana
Map of Gary within Indiana Located in Lake County, Indiana
Median home value -66% vs IN
$86,989
IN $254k
Median income -46% vs IN
$38,731
IN $72k

Gary is a city in Lake County, Indiana, United States, 25 miles from downtown Chicago, Illinois.

6

No. 6 most affordable place in Indiana

Logansport, IN

17,790 peopleSnackAbility 5/10down 3
5/10
Logansport, IN
Source: Public domain
$47,291 median income · $786 median rent · #12 home prices in Indiana
Map of Logansport within Indiana Located in Cass County, Indiana
Median home value -40% vs IN
$153,143
IN $254k
Median income -34% vs IN
$47,291
IN $72k

Situated about 60 miles southwest of Fort Wayne, Peru ranks as the sixth most affordable place to call home in Indiana. Peru was once the winter headquarters for several famous circuses, like the Ringling Brothers and Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show. It’s maintained that heritage into the 21st century with the annual Peru Circus City Festival and Parade, amateur circus performances, and the Circus Hall of Fame. That’s not the only outside-the-box entertainment option in Peru, though; there’s also the Grissom Air Museum for folks interested in learning more about military aircraft. For more standard activities, there’s always fishing or kayaking on Mississinewa Lake. Homes in Peru are the 12th cheapest in Indiana at $153,143, which is a big contributor to the city’s low cost of living. The median income in Peru is $47,291 and the media rent is $786.

7

No. 7 most affordable place in Indiana

Connersville, IN

13,109 peopleSnackAbility 4/10
4/10
Connersville, IN
Source: Public domain
$48,854 median income · $787 median rent · #16 home prices in Indiana
Map of Connersville within Indiana Located in Fayette County, Indiana
Median home value -38% vs IN
$157,813
IN $254k
Median income -32% vs IN
$48,854
IN $72k

Connersville, located in Fayette County about 70 miles east of Indianapolis, shines as a great savings spot in Indiana. The city’s $157,813 median home price and $787 rent push the city to the top of the list. Particularly in intra-state rankings, home prices and rent will be the most significant factors in determining how expensive a place in Indiana is.

The overall cost of living is 10.0% lower than the Hoosier average.

8

No. 8 most affordable place in Indiana

Huntingburg, IN

6,396 peopleSnackAbility 6/10up 22
6/10
Huntingburg, IN
Source: Public domain
$54,421 median income · $887 median rent · #62 home prices in Indiana
Map of Huntingburg within Indiana Located in Dubois County, Indiana
Median home value -5% vs IN
$240,498
IN $254k
Median income -24% vs IN
$54,421
IN $72k

Huntingburg is a city in Patoka Township, Dubois County, in the U.S. state of Indiana. The population was 6,057 at the 2010 census.

9

No. 9 most affordable place in Indiana

Hartford City, IN

5,794 peopleSnackAbility 6/10up 9
6/10
Hartford City, IN
Source: Public domain
$41,752 median income · $730 median rent · #5 home prices in Indiana
Located in Blackford County, Indiana
Median home value -45% vs IN
$139,704
IN $254k
Median income -42% vs IN
$41,752
IN $72k

Located between Indianapolis and Fort Wayne, Hartford City ranks as the ninth cheapest city in Indiana. Indiana is already a stand-out for being one of the cheapest states in America, but Hartford City takes that to the extreme with the fifth cheapest homes in the state. Hartford City residents earn a median income of $41,752, putting Hartford City in the top five statewide for home price to income ratio.

10

No. 10 most affordable place in Indiana

Anderson, IN

55,367 peopleSnackAbility 5/10up 16
5/10
Anderson, IN
Source: Public domain
$46,909 median income · $925 median rent · #3 home prices in Indiana
Map of Anderson within Indiana Located in Madison County, Indiana
Median home value -47% vs IN
$135,174
IN $254k
Median income -35% vs IN
$46,909
IN $72k

Anderson is a city in and the county seat of Madison County, Indiana, United States. It is the principal city of the Anderson, Indiana Metropolitan Statistical Area which encompasses Madison County. Anderson is the headquarters of the Church of God and home of Anderson University, which is affiliated with that denomination. Highlights of the city include the historic Paramount Theatre and the Gruenewald Historic House.

The receipts

Compare the top ten

Pick a metric. The bars rescale. The red line is Indiana’s statewide median.

City Cost of living index vs IN
1 Muncie 80
2 Marion 80
3 New Castle 80
4 Peru 80
5 Gary 81
6 Logansport 81
7 Connersville 81
8 Huntingburg 81
9 Hartford City 81
10 Anderson 82
City Median home value vs IN
1 Muncie $151,291 -40%
2 Marion $136,313 -46%
3 New Castle $164,336 -35%
4 Peru $149,304 -41%
5 Gary $86,989 -66%
6 Logansport $153,143 -40%
7 Connersville $157,813 -38%
8 Huntingburg $240,498 -5%
9 Hartford City $139,704 -45%
10 Anderson $135,174 -47%

Indiana statewide median: $254,122

City Median income vs IN
1 Muncie $44,471 -38%
2 Marion $43,343 -40%
3 New Castle $51,606 -28%
4 Peru $46,159 -36%
5 Gary $38,731 -46%
6 Logansport $47,291 -34%
7 Connersville $48,854 -32%
8 Huntingburg $54,421 -24%
9 Hartford City $41,752 -42%
10 Anderson $46,909 -35%

Indiana statewide median: $71,957

City Median rent vs IN
1 Muncie $904
2 Marion $805
3 New Castle $781
4 Peru $826
5 Gary $1,012
6 Logansport $786
7 Connersville $787
8 Huntingburg $887
9 Hartford City $730
10 Anderson $925
City Population vs IN
1 Muncie 64,751
2 Marion 27,531
3 New Castle 17,367
4 Peru 10,901
5 Gary 68,113
6 Logansport 17,790
7 Connersville 13,109
8 Huntingburg 6,396
9 Hartford City 5,794
10 Anderson 55,367

On the map

Where your money goes furthest in Indiana

Saturday Night Science

Methodology: How we determined the most affordable places to live in the Hoosier State for 2026

Determining affordability for places in Indiana boils down to how much it costs to live here.

You need to understand your costs relative to what people in the rest of the state are paying.

With that logic in mind, we derived several cost of living statistics from the latest Census American Community Survey 2020-2024 for Indiana using Saturday Night Science. We indexed the cost of living statistics across the following categories:

  • Housing
  • Transportation
  • Services
  • Groceries
  • Healthcare
  • Utilities

These are then weighted together to produce an overall cost of living index where 100 is the United States average. Anything below 100 is relatively affordable. Anything over 100 is relatively expensive.

We applied the biggest weight to housing as it typically accounts for 25% or more of your budget. Additionally, housing costs are the highest variant cost across a state. We then compare these cost of living metrics for each place in Indiana to figure out which is the least expensive.

The “Cost of Living Index” allows you to rank all of the 122 places in Indiana that have more than 5,000 people from least expensive to most expensive. Any ties went to the larger city.

The place in Indiana with the lowest cost of living according to the data is Muncie.

We updated this article for 2026. This report reflects our eleventh time ranking the cheapest places to live in Indiana.

The full plate

Cheapest Places To Live In Indiana

Click any column to sort. Search by city name.

RankCityPopulationCost Of Living IndexMedian IncomeHome PricesRent
1Muncie64,75180$44,471$151,291$904
2Marion27,53180$43,343$136,313$805
3New Castle17,36780$51,606$164,336$781
4Peru10,90180$46,159$149,304$826
5Gary68,11381$38,731$86,989$1,012
6Logansport17,79081$47,291$153,143$786
7Connersville13,10981$48,854$157,813$787
8Huntingburg6,39681$54,421$240,498$887
9Hartford City5,79481$41,752$139,704$730
10Anderson55,36782$46,909$135,174$925
11Wabash10,35882$53,410$179,809$739
12Elwood8,35682$53,280$148,429$860
13Portland6,41682$51,513$162,775$763
14Linton5,26082$45,440$171,819$812
15Huntington17,03083$56,520$192,024$879
16Vincennes16,58683$53,637$164,630$793
17Gas City6,07683$55,982$157,194$901
18Elkhart53,73384$51,028$222,794$998
19East Chicago26,02284$42,125$128,171$854
20Lake Station13,18584$59,591$151,774$1,124
21Plymouth10,66484$58,623$238,868$957
22Tell City7,50584$52,949$181,285$657
23Boonville6,70284$63,580$230,217$873
24Rushville6,03684$53,434$202,258$911
25Winchester5,28484$52,439$152,403$756
26Alexandria5,15584$64,317$182,198$801
27South Bend103,08585$55,786$192,340$1,033
28Mishawaka51,02185$54,291$206,367$1,070
29Richmond35,58185$45,399$156,510$822
30La Porte22,44985$59,307$271,481$948
31Bluffton10,52985$57,539$183,603$732
32Salem6,48985$56,538$208,086$690
33Hammond76,76886$55,504$170,817$1,134
34Shelbyville20,29686$55,602$222,049$995
35Crawfordsville16,49186$55,033$219,773$857
36Frankfort15,91786$57,412$209,856$898
37Beech Grove14,91386$49,973$191,935$1,091
38Princeton8,37286$57,618$187,283$1,022
39Garrett6,64286$64,179$187,134$858
40Rochester6,21586$57,008$210,468$867
41Monticello5,49686$52,798$235,505$927
42Kokomo59,12287$55,360$180,398$939
43Terre Haute58,42787$43,126$155,802$922
44Washington12,36787$50,331$147,888$858
45Decatur9,81187$58,646$229,668$820
46Brazil7,83187$52,055$188,386$869
47North Vernon7,07887$51,429$212,243$938
48Rensselaer5,57387$60,331$242,741$936
49Lawrenceburg5,17987$51,250$248,401$767
50Evansville116,11688$53,387$198,977$975
51Lafayette71,15988$53,716$262,731$1,079
52Goshen34,42088$59,184$275,120$1,093
53Michigan City31,81488$53,089$187,488$967
54Bedford13,83788$49,553$207,924$828
55Martinsville11,93388$60,177$288,805$983
56Kendallville10,55688$58,939$220,523$821
57Scottsburg7,36288$38,578$187,044$831
58Tipton5,28088$59,828$237,894$848
59Lebanon17,81289$65,154$299,032$962
60Warsaw16,76889$61,035$271,691$1,066
61New Haven15,69889$70,970$240,073$998
62Columbia City9,89789$68,089$279,168$963
63Nappanee6,81589$68,892$288,904$856
64New Whiteland5,70489$89,918$228,047$1,465
65New Albany37,58190$54,710$235,058$1,026
66Jasper15,99190$68,817$266,264$810
67Auburn13,56590$68,750$275,151$865
68Greensburg12,22990$62,655$261,666$859
69Greencastle9,86490$55,565$243,386$908
70Angola9,40890$64,540$302,980$933
71Westville5,27990$60,794$357,284$1,019
72Fort Wayne268,58991$61,422$242,385$999
73Seymour22,37191$64,426$230,829$1,011
74Charlestown8,29491$77,288$302,064$1,033
75Batesville7,28291$62,292$317,505$847
76Mount Vernon6,40091$62,263$221,083$783
77Merrillville36,47692$67,587$240,329$1,282
78Speedway13,96892$60,147$236,684$1,141
79Madison12,22392$61,183$240,680$820
80Greenfield24,94093$76,127$285,066$1,177
81Clarksville22,01693$60,467$203,069$1,110
82Mooresville9,75193$68,983$308,099$1,089
83Ellettsville6,69893$90,213$274,445$855
84Indianapolis885,86094$66,219$229,209$1,156
85Highland23,68094$78,062$262,852$1,230
86Whiteland5,17394$96,944$296,965$1,661
87Jeffersonville51,04395$70,930$251,611$1,148
88Lawrence49,51795$74,022$268,725$1,178
89Hobart29,55895$75,160$238,196$1,206
90Griffith16,27395$76,636$247,099$1,235
91Danville11,71495$97,083$337,029$1,151
92Winona Lake5,08095$82,188$297,378$1,132
93Greenwood66,02996$83,608$326,491$1,312
94Columbus51,82496$77,456$276,890$1,157
95Portage38,08296$76,276$264,578$1,231
96Valparaiso34,73396$69,872$355,845$1,224
97Franklin26,16896$82,380$279,168$1,186
98Pendleton5,32196$86,806$334,739$1,209
99Sellersburg10,13797$72,179$296,867$1,151
100Cumberland6,26797$87,364$289,409$1,157

Source: U.S. Census ACS 2020-2024, cost-of-living data. 122 places with more than 5,000 residents.

Summary

Indiana Affordability Summary

This is an accurate list of the most affordable places to live in Indiana for 2026, if you’re looking at the cost of living numbers in Indiana.

The cheapest cities in Indiana are Muncie, Marion, New Castle, Peru, Gary, Logansport, Connersville, Huntingburg, Hartford City, and Anderson.

Chris Kolmar
About the author

Chris Kolmar has been in the real estate business for almost ten years now. He originally worked for Movoto Real Estate as the director of marketing before founding HomeSnacks.

He believes the key to finding the right place to live comes down to looking at the data, reading about things to do, and, most importantly, checking it out yourself before you move.

If you've been looking for a place to live in the past several years, you've probably stumbled upon his writing already.

You can find out more about him on LinkedIn or his website.

Get the SnackPack →