These Are The 10 Safest Small Cities In America

We looked at the small cities and towns in America to determine which are the safest, in terms of property and violent crimes.

HomeSnacks is reader-supported. When you click through real estate links on our site, we earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.
This article is an opinion based on facts and is meant as infotainment. Don’t freak out.

Swipe left for slideshow

There’s a common denominator that all safe small cities have.
They are the places where people sleep safer at night, where shootings and beatings don’t dominate the local news. The best small towns in America to raise kids, and awesome places to retire.
Because if crime is really low, everyone wants to be there (crummy weather aside).
The small cities below all share those qualities. There might be some surprises on this list, but when you look at the unbiased data, it’s hard to argue against. We had more than 10 million people read our worst cities in a state series, which was featured in hundreds of media outlets, including an NPR feature.
So we know what we’re talking about.
After analyzing every small town in America, here is our list of the safest small cities to live in the United States:

  1. Lewisboro, NY
  2. Ridgefield, CT
  3. Hopkinton, MA
  4. Sudbury, MA
  5. Wilton, CT
  6. Sharon, MA
  7. Brecksville, OH
  8. Franklin, MA
  9. Western Springs, IL
  10. Norfolk, MA

You might be surprised to see some of the small towns on this list. We understand there’s a lot of good in every place. However, according to data (which doesn’t measure things like beauty, ‘friendly people’ and community involvement), there aren’t safer options in America for making a place home.
The most dangerous small city to live in America? College Park, GA. More on that later.

How do you decide if a place is safe or not?

In order to rank the safest small American cities, we had to determine what makes a place dangerous. It isn’t a stretch to assume that states where people are being killed and beaten up on a weekly basis are a pretty bad place to be.
So we scraped the internet for those criteria, and it spit out the answer. Like magic.

How we crunched the numbers

We threw a lot of criteria at this one in order to get the best, most complete results possible. Using FBI crime data, this is the criteria we used:

  • Number of murders per year per state
  • Number of robberies per year per state
  • Number of car thefts per year per state
  • Number of assaults per year per state

If you’d like to see the complete list of cities, scroll to the bottom of this post to see a chart of the top 250 small cities. We kept the population to cities under 100,000 for this ranking.
Note: We get the crime numbers from the FBI, which gets its crime numbers from the states themselves. This list is based on data, and is entirely unbiased. It’s also not a testament to the effectiveness of local law enforcement.

1. Lewisboro, NY


Population: 12,712
Property crime: 10th lowest in the nation
Violent crime: Lowest in the nation
If you’re looking for the absolute safest small city to live in America, than look no further than Lewisboro, NY. In fact, most of the cities on this list are in the northeast region of the United States.
Lewisboro, located right along the Connecticut state line, has the lowest violent crime rate in the state. In fact, there were none for the last reporting year. That’s right. Zero. Zilch.
Some of the cities on this list can’t go an hour without some type of violent crime.

2. Ridgefield, CT


Population: 25,288
Property crime: 16th lowest in the nation
Violent crime: 10th lowest in the nation
Right next door to Lewisboro, on the Connecticut side of the border, is the small, cute city of Ridgefield, where things are also pretty peachy keen when you look at the data.
Ridgefield is in the bottom 20 in the nation for both property and violent crimes, according to the FBI. Plus, Ridgefield has all sorts of festivals and artsy things happening throughout the year, including the annual Nutmeg Festival.

3. Hopkinton, MA


Population: 16,209
Property crime: 18th lowest in the nation
Violent crime: 17th lowest in the nation
Just a short drive outside of Boston, right along the 495 Beltline is the small city of Hopkinton, Massachusetts, where you don’t have to worry about crime very often.
The starting point for the Boston Marathon, Hopkinton’s population is doing pretty well financially. Only 1% of the population lives in poverty.
Money Magazine and other larger publications have called Hopkinton as one of the best places to live in America for good reason.

4. Sudbury, MA


Population: 18,492
Property crime: 24th lowest in the nation
Violent crime: 13th lowest in the nation
Just a short bike ride from Hopkinton is the small Boston suburb of Sudbury, which ranks really low for number of violent crimes per capita each year. In fact, there was only one violent crime reported here last year.
To make things even better, there were only about 5 property crimes here a month, on average. That’s just absurd.

5. Wilton, CT


Population: 18,807
Property crime: 26th lowest in the nation
Violent crime: 12th lowest in the nation
Continuing our trend of cities in the northeast, we come to Wilton, a small city along the New York State line. Wilton is a suburb of the larger cities in Connecticut such as Norwalk, Bridgeport and Fairfield, but many residents undoubtedly commute into NYC.
CNN once called this one of the top 10 places to live in the country, citing the household income levels which average about $300,000 each.

6. Sharon, MA


Population: 18,177
Property crime: 51st lowest in the nation
Violent crime: Tied, lowest in the nation
There are very few small towns and cities in America where a violent crime doesn’t occur each year, and Sharon, Massachusetts is one of them. If you work in Boston and you’re lucky enough to commute in from this awesome, safe suburb, then you’ve got it made.
For perspective, Alexandria Louisiana saw 858 violent crimes in a single year. And the cities are almost the same size, population wise.

7. Brecksville, OH


Population: 13,505
Property crime: 73rd lowest in the nation
Violent crime: Tied, lowest in the nation
Brecksville is also one of a few small cities and towns where a property crime didn’t happen last year. And it’s also the most safe small city or town in the entire midwest (and the first on this list that isn’t in the northeast).
Brecksville is a Cleveland ‘burb, and where most of the wealthier, more successful Cleveland-area business owners and executives call home. Brecksville’s great schools, amenities, proximity to nature, and closeness to Cleveland underscores its desirability.

8. Franklin, MA


Population: 32,842
Property crime: 25th lowest in the nation
Violent crime: 40th lowest in the nation
Another Boston suburb, Franklin is down near the Rhode Island state line. Here, crime is a bit higher than the other cities on this list, but for a city of 33,000, a total of 5 violent crimes a year is still very impressive.
Downtown, on Main Street and Union Street, there are lots of smaller, quaint, cute shops and restaurants, adding to this small town’s desirability.

9. Western Springs, IL


Population: 13,217
Property crime: 27th lowest in the nation
Violent crime: 54th lowest in the nation
Western Springs is one of the wealthier, quieter Chicago suburbs where crime is just simply something that happens in other places. In fact, Western Springs only saw two violent crimes last year, but because it’s so small, it ranks ‘only’ 54th on the violent crime ranking list.
BusinessWeek called Western Springs one of the top 50 places to live in America at one point. The rankings were based on school test scores, cost of living, activities, number of schools and safety.

10. Norfolk, MA


Population: 11,825
Property crime: 14th lowest in the nation
Violent crime: 70th lowest in the nation
Rounding out our tour of the safest small cities and towns to live in America, we come to Norfolk, Massachusetts, which is not surprisingly, in the northeast. Sure, it’s a small town that had a couple of violent crimes last year, but overall, you could find much more dangerous places to live.
Norfolk only saw 22 property crimes for the entire year, which is less than one a month. Does that make you jealous of where you live?

There You Have It

If you’re looking at small American cities and towns where murders, rapes and robberies happen at a much lower rate than average, this is an accurate list.
If you’re also curious enough, here are the most dangerous small cities and towns to live in America, according to science.

  1. College Park, Georgia
  2. Gallup, New Mexico
  3. Florida City, Florida
  4. Bellmead, Texas
  5. Lumberton, North Carolina
City State Rank Population Violent Crime Per 100k Property Crime Per 100k
Lewisboro Town New York 1.000000000 12,712 0.0 39.3
Ridgefield Connecticut 2.000000000 25,288 4.0 257.0
Hopkinton Massachusetts 3.000000000 16,209 6.2 265.3
Sudbury Massachusetts 4.000000000 18,592 5.4 317.3
Wilton Connecticut 5.000000000 18,807 5.3 324.3
Sharon Massachusetts 6.000000000 18,177 0.0 445.6
Chatham Township New Jersey 7.000000000 10,698 9.3 383.2
Grosse Ile Township Michigan 8.000000000 10,150 9.9 403.9
Brecksville Ohio 9.000000000 13,505 0.0 481.3
Franklin Massachusetts 10.000000000 32,857 15.2 319.6
Western Springs Illinois 11.000000000 13,217 15.1 332.9
Norfolk Massachusetts 12.000000000 11,835 16.9 185.9
Clinton Township New Jersey 13.000000000 13,257 7.5 460.1
Ridgefield New Jersey 14.000000000 11,277 8.9 461.1
Buckingham Township Pennsylvania 15.000000000 20,405 14.7 401.9
Northampton Township Pennsylvania 16.000000000 39,692 15.1 413.2
Campton Hills Illinois 17.000000000 11,351 17.6 299.5
Upper Providence Township, Delaware County Pennsylvania 18.000000000 10,354 19.3 251.1
New Milford New Jersey 19.000000000 16,650 12.0 468.5
Weston Connecticut 20.000000000 10,417 19.2 316.8
Montgomery Township New Jersey 20.000000000 22,547 8.9 514.5
Groton Massachusetts 22.000000000 11,260 8.9 532.9
Wyckoff Township New Jersey 23.000000000 17,011 11.8 505.6
Hillsdale New Jersey 24.000000000 10,487 19.1 391.0
Shrewsbury Massachusetts 25.000000000 36,578 5.5 571.4
Woolwich Township New Jersey 26.000000000 11,523 17.4 459.9
Harrison Town New York 27.000000000 28,130 17.8 458.6
Glen Cove New York 28.000000000 27,241 22.0 356.1
Frederick Colorado 29.000000000 10,607 18.9 452.5
South Fayette Township Pennsylvania 30.000000000 15,317 6.5 587.6
Branchburg Township New Jersey 31.000000000 14,581 20.6 445.8
North Castle Town New York 32.000000000 12,224 16.4 515.4
Pennridge Regional Pennsylvania 33.000000000 11,050 9.0 588.2
Medway Massachusetts 34.000000000 13,159 22.8 440.8
Willistown Township Pennsylvania 35.000000000 10,760 18.6 501.9
New Canaan Connecticut 36.000000000 20,302 4.9 640.3
Rye New York 36.000000000 16,016 25.0 337.2
Weston Massachusetts 38.000000000 12,015 25.0 349.6
Tenafly New Jersey 39.000000000 14,773 6.8 629.5
Norton Massachusetts 40.000000000 19,477 20.5 492.9
Brunswick Hills Township Ohio 40.000000000 10,202 19.6 509.7
Cedar Grove Township New Jersey 42.000000000 12,501 16.0 584.0
Kent Town New York 42.000000000 13,401 14.9 597.0
Hudson Ohio 44.000000000 22,526 17.8 559.4
New Britain Township Pennsylvania 45.000000000 11,034 18.1 561.9
Warren Township New Jersey 46.000000000 16,021 25.0 455.7
River Edge New Jersey 47.000000000 11,573 17.3 587.6
Franconia Township Pennsylvania 48.000000000 13,263 22.6 512.7
South Park Township Pennsylvania 48.000000000 13,571 29.5 294.7
Madison Connecticut 50.000000000 18,302 10.9 650.2

About Nick Johnson

Nick Johnson earned his masters in Business Administration from the Drucker School At Claremont Graduate University. He has written for 39 publications across the country and ran the media relations department at Movoto, a real estate portal based in San Francisco. He has been featured in over 500 publications as an expert in real estate and as an authority on real estate trends. .

Nick's the creator of the HomeSnacks YouTube channel that now has over 260,000 subscribers and is an excellent source to learn about different parts of the country.